Randall gets the same fate he did in monsters inc and this time doesn't get saved

The Coachman : He chases Pinocchio to the cliff and falls to his death when he tries to catch him.

Odalia Blight : I know she's not considered Karma Houdini, but we've never seen a punishment strong enough for her. She is either killed by Emperor Belos before possessing Raine or arrested and imprisoned at the end

Art the clown: banished to the final layer of hell and never able to visit earth ever again

Harley Sawer: killed brutally by one of the playtime co monsters

The Smile entity : Forced to go through EVERYTHING he put his victims through , I'd prefer this punishment be given by God himself if the entity really is a demon.

The Coachman : Turned into a donkey and sold of to a plantation to be worked to death.

Punchline : Having her face carved out by joker (joker himself deserves one of these fates but I'm too overwhelmed by all the things that should be done to him)

Odalia Blight : Striped of her riches , resources and forced onto the streets y'know cuz she's an elitist

Emma Grossman : Cut piece by piece from the bottom up , a piece for each one of her victims till she's dead (I actually do feel bad abt this one since she's still a child/minor at the end of the day)

The Qu : They are deafeated but It's never specified how their defeated so in my opinion the most karmic defeat would to be enslaved by the species they terrorized for so long.

ANY rapist that's gotten away with their crimes should be raped in turn then put to death , simple.

Invictus: Mooncake becomes a Titan and uses his powers to annihilate Invictus for good.

Conrad (Berserk) - Maybe he could be dropped to his death?

Joker (2008 Graphic Novel) - He could be called a fraud by another Joker and locked up.

Pinocchio (Pinocchio Unstrung) - He could be called a fraud and used as fire wood.

1. Henry from Portrait of a Serial Killer needs to join his "friend" Otis in the afterlife via being hunted down & shot.

Joker (2008 Graphic Novel) isn't Pure Evil, as he has a sympathetic moment of crying inconsolably into Harvey's legs.

Emma Grossman to attempt another frame job but unintentionally frames herself, and in investigation, the full extent of what she's done to be revealed. Nice bit of karma. I also don't feel bad at all in noting that she's a minor, as she has full moral agency (though is very charismatic, I'll give you that).

Femto: his wings ripped off and restored back into his crippled form and displayed for the world to see. Subverting his impressive deeds and facade.

Ubik, being verbally deconstructed into madness and into giving up his powers

Black Philip: seduced by Thomasin and tricked into abandoning his coven and robbed of his powers

Chucky: someone places him inside a doll intended for children, but is completely inanimate and forced to take part in all the childish games with children he hates and incapable of any harm until he is eventually thrown away. (Same for his wife Tiffany, a NPE)

...aaand Mary Shaw. Beat to death with one of her own dolls.

Am : All of the humans he tortures either die or somehow break free of him, leaving him all alone to do nothing but wait for his demise, which may be like billions of billions of years, all while he remains fully self aware and sentient, making it an essentially unending torture.

The Coachman's cronies turn on him and poison him (Or whatever he did that turned Pinnochio into a donkey), turning him into a donkey for eternity.